Tom H. C. Anderson - Next Gen Market Research™Cover Letter Customer Service Technical Support Cover Letter For Customer Service Teller Cover Letter Customer Service Uk Virtual Customer Service Cover Letter Volunteer Customer Service Cover Letter Cover Letter Customer Service Without Experience Cover Letter With Customer Service Experience Cover Letter With Banking Amp Customer Service Cover Letter Contents Include Cover Letter Content For Resume Cover Letter For Content Writer Cover Letter For A Content Writer Cover Letter For Web Content Analyst Cover Letter For A Content Manager Cover Letter For Web Content Administrator Appropriate Cover Letter Content Content Analyst Cover Letter Best Cover Letter Content Basic Cover Letter Content Cover Letter Content Coordinator Cv Cover Letter Content Cover Letter For Content Developer Digital Content Cover Letter Content Director Cover Letter Cover Letter Content Editor Employment Cover Letter Content Cover Letter For Content Manager Cover Letter For Web Content Specialist Good Cover Letter Content What Is Cover Letter Content Cover Letter Content Manager Cover Letter Web Content Manager Content Moderator Cover Letter Cover Letter Of Content Writer Online Content Cover Letter Cover Letter Content Producer Cover Letter Paragraph Content Proper Cover Letter Content Cover Letter Resume Content Cover Letter Content Specialist Content Strategist Cover Letter Typical Cover Letter Content Cover Letter Content Writer Cover Letter Web Content Cover Letter Web Content Specialist Cover Letter For Web Content Assessor Cover Letter Closing Paragraph Cover Letter End Paragraph Great Cover Letter Closing Paragraph Closing Paragraph For Cover Letter Good Closing Paragraph For Cover Letter Best Closing Paragraph For Cover Letter Good Cover Letter Closing Paragraphs Closing Paragraph In Cover Letter Good Closing Paragraph In Cover Letter Closing Paragraph Of Cover Letter Closing Paragraph To Cover Letter Cover Letter Conclusion Statements Cover Letter Conclusion Sentences Cover Letter Closing Account Best Cover Letter Conclusion Cv Cover Letter Conclusion Cover Letter English Conclusion Conclusion For Cover Letter Good Cover Letter Conclusion Great Cover Letter Conclusion Cover Letter In Conclusion Cover Letter Internship Conclusion Conclusion Of Cover Letter Cover Letter Closing Phrases Academic Cover Letter Closing Paragraph Cover Letter Closing Best Regards Resume Cover Letter Conclusion Cover Letter Closing Sincerely Cover Letter Closing Spacing Conclusion To Cover Letter Writing A Cover Letter Conclusion Cover Letter Closing Yours Cover Letter Career Change Career Change Cover Letter 2012 Cover Letter Career Change Administrative Assistant Cover Letter Career Change Accounting Cover Letter And Career Change Attorney Cover Letter Career Change Cover Letter Explaining A Career Change Career Change Cover Letter Administrative Cover Letter Career Change Banking Best Cover Letter Career Change Cv Cover Letter Career Change Change Career Direction Cover Letter Cover Letter Career Change No Experience Cover Letter Explaining Career Change Executive Cover Letter Career Change Cover Letter Career Change Finance Cover Letter Change Career Focus Cover Letter For Career Field Change Cover Letter For Career Change To Sales Cover Letter For Career Change Position General Cover Letter Career Change How To Write Cover Letter Career Change Career Change Cover Letter Hospitality Career Change Cover Letter Help Cover Letter Career Change It Cover Letter For Career Change Into Teaching Cover Letter Change In Career Path Cover Letter Explaining Change In Career Addressing Career Change In Cover Letter Mention Career Change In Cover Letter Career Change Into Education Cover Letter Cover Letter Lawyer Career Change Legal Cover Letter Career Change Entry Level Cover Letter Career Change Cover Letter Career Change Marketing Cover Letter Mid Career Change Monster Cover Letter Career Change Mention Career Change Cover Letter Mba Career Change Cover Letter Change My Career Cover Letter Cover Letter Career Change Nurse New Career Change Cover Letter Cover Letter Change Of Career Cover Letter Change Of Career Path Cover Letter That Explains Change Of Career Cover Letter Career Change Position Career Change Cover Letter Pdf Career Change Cover Letter Public Relations Persuasive Career Change Cover Letter Cover Letter Career Change To Sales Speculative Cover Letter Career Change Customer Service Cover Letter Career Change Career Change Cover Letter Social Work Cover Letter Career Change Teacher Cover Letter Career Change To Accounting Cover Letter With Career Change Cover Letter Consulting Firm Cover Letter Consulting Position Cover Letter Consulting Internship Cover Letter For Consulting Firm Cover Letter For Consulting Internship Cover Letter For Consulting Group Cover Letter For Consulting Proposal Cover Letter For Consulting Services Cover Letter For Consulting Application Cover Letter Consulting Analyst Cover Letter Consulting Application Cover Letter Actuarial Consulting Cover Letter Abap Consultant Cover Letter Art Consultant Cover Letter As Consultant Cover Letter For Consulting Analyst Position Cover Letter Consulting Bain Cover Letter Business Consulting Cover Letter Boston Consulting Cover Letter Beauty Consultant Cover Letter Bridal Consultant Cover Letter Brand Consultant Cover Letter Bi Consultant Cover Letter Sap Basis Consultant Cover Letter Consulting Company Cover Letter Consulting Columbia Cover Letter Cosmetics Consultant Cover Letter Career Consultant Healthcare Consulting Cover Letter Cover Letter For Computer Consultant Cover Letter For Cruise Consultant Cover Letter For Crm Consultant Cover Letter For Communication Consultant Cover Letter Consulting Doc Cover Letter Consulting Deloitte Cover Letter Diversity Consultant Cover Letter Business Development Consultant Development Consulting Cover Letter Consulting Director Cover Letter Deloitte Consulting Cover Letter Address Cover Letter Consulting Engineer Cover Letter Environmental Consulting Cover Letter Economic Consulting Cover Letter Employment Consultant Cover Letter Education Consultant Cover Letter For Consulting Cover Letter For Consulting Analyst Cover Letter For Consulting Agreement Cover Letter Financial Consulting Cover Letter For Consulting Role Cover Letter Consulting Graduate Cover Letter Boston Consulting Group Cover Letter For Graduate Consulting Position Generic Cover Letter Consulting Cover Letter Healthcare Consulting Cover Letter Hr Consultant Cover Letter Health Consultant Cover Letter For Healthcare Consultant Position Cover Letter Sap Hr Consultant Consulting Cover Letter Harvard Consulting Cover Letter Help Cover Letter Consulting Industry Cover Letter Consulting It Cover Letter Implementation Consultant Cover Letter Investment Consultant Cover Letter Image Consultant Cover Letter Immigration Consultant Cover Letter Insurance Consultant Cover Letter Consultant Junior Killer Consulting Cover Letter Cover Letter Lek Consulting Cover Letter Leaving Consulting Cover Letter Leasing Consultant Cover Letter Lactation Consultant Cover Letter Legal Consultant Cover Letter Consulting Entry Level Cover Letter Weight Loss Consultant Cover Letter For Leasing Consultant Resume Cover Letter For Lean Consultant Cover Letter Consulting Mba Cover Letter Consulting Management Cover Letter Mortgage Consultant Cover Letter Medical Consultant Cover Letter Media Consultant Cover Letter Travel Consultant No Experience Cover Letter For Nurse Consultant Cover Letter Clinical Nurse Consultant Consulting Cover Letter No Experience Cover Letter Non Profit Consulting Nonprofit Consulting Cover Letter Cover Letter Consulting Oxford Cover Letter Offering Consulting Services Cover Letter Of Consulting Cover Letter Oracle Consultant Cover Letter For Operations Consultant Consulting Cover Letter Oliver Wyman Outstanding Consulting Cover Letter Cover Letter Consulting Phd Cover Letter Consulting Proposal Cover Letter Consulting Pwc Cover Letter Consulting Pdf Cover Letter Political Consulting Cover Letter Placement Consultant Cover Letter Property Consultant Cover Letter Peoplesoft Consultant Cover Letter Project Consultant Cover Letter Consultant Role Cover Letter Recruitment Consultant Cover Letter Recruitment Consultant Position Cover Letter Research Consultant Cover Letter Recruitment Consultant Trainee Cover Letter Resume Consultant Cover Letter Risk Consultant Cover Letter Recruitment Consultant Role Cover Letter Reservation Consultant Cover Letter Consulting Strategy Cover Letter Sales Consultant Cover Letter Sap Consultant Cover Letter Sustainability Consultant Cover Letter Senior Consultant Cover Letter Software Consultant Cover Letter To Consulting Cover Letter Travel Consultant Cover Letter Technical Consultant Cover Letter Technology Consultant Cover Letter Tax Consultant Cover Letter Training Consultant Cover Letter Consulting Uk Cover Letter Consulting Undergraduate Undergrad Consulting Cover Letter Consulting Cover Letter Victor Cheng Consulting Cover Letter Vault Vanderbilt Consulting Cover Letter Cover Letter Why Consulting Cover Letter For Consulting Work Cover Letter For Travel Consultant With No Experience Cover Letter For Wireless Consultant Cover Letter For Wedding Consultant Cover Letter For Sales Consultant With No Experience Cover Letter For Wine Consultant Consulting Cover Letter Wetfeet Consulting Cover Letter Wall Street Oasis Cover Letter End Statements Closing Statement For A Cover Letter Closing Statement For Cover Letter Closing Statement In Cover Letter Closing Statement On Cover Letter Resume Cover Letter Closing Statement Strong Cover Letter Closing Statements Closing Statement To Cover Letter Cover Letter Nursing Assistant Cna 1 Cover Letter Cover Letter For Cna Application Cover Letter For A Cna Position Cover Letter For A Cna Cover Letter Can Find Address Cover Letter Can Do Attitude Cover Letter For A Cna Without Experience Cover Letter Can Find A Name Cover Letter For A Certified Nursing Assistant Cover Letter For A Nursing Assistant Best Cna Cover Letter Cover Letter Cna No Experience Cna Cover Letter Entry Level Cover Letter For Cna Cover Letter For Cna Position

More Than Market Research - Gain The Information Advantage

Tom H. C. Anderson - Next Gen Market Research™ header image 6

Rethinking Rethink

March 28th, 2012 · 3 Comments

Random thoughts from this year’s ARF Re:think 2012

The Advertising Research Foundation’s annual Rethink conference just ended. As the biggest annual research event here in the north east I always enjoy catching up there with both new and old colleagues.

Buzzworthy Presentations

Two of Monday’s presentations seemed to catch a lot of attention (and offend some). One of these which attendees were still buzzing about yesterday was a presentation by Karen Nelson-Field of Ehrenberg-Bass Institute for Marketing Science. She challenged researchers on the importance and uniqueness of social media and asked whether the current investments really have been worthwhile.

Facebook Likes for instance certainly seem to have little correlation with engagement or increased sales, and even those among us who are more active on Facebook, even with the micro targeting possible, find it difficult to remember a compelling ad there. Few many of us return ever to a brand site.

Personally I think the problem lies not in the value of social media as a marketing tool, but more in how marketers are approaching it. More on this later.

The second source of buzz carried over from Monday was a panel entitled “Getting Ahead of Change” in which CEO’s of Nielsen, Millward Brown, GfK, Kantar, and Ipsos tried to dissuade the audience from the common belief that research innovation isn’t coming from them directly, but only from startups which later are bought up by the “big guys”.

While I’m obviously biased in this area having spent many years with some of the larger firms before starting Anderson Analytics (OdinText), most of those who attended seemed to continue to share my bias after the presentation. While the ‘big guys’ have traditionally had some advantage in scaling certain metrics, they certainly don’t seem too innovative and most of their acquisitions eventually just end up competing against each other ( It mainly serves to decrease margins and is more of a case of 1 + 1 = 1/2). I would also argue that with the rise of API’s and web data becoming equally available to all, this one benefit of scale will also become less of an advantage.

Digital Research and Tracking

I made a point to attend two consecutive Unilever case studies focused on digital research yesterday. The first was a collaboration between TNS’s Cymfony and Compete.com, and attempted to draw insights between what people say online and what they actually do. An interesting idea for sure, but I was rather disappointed that the data had been analyzed in isolation. The research would have been far more compelling had the data sets been linked, something that we’ve looked at in the recent past and I l know is already possible, privacy issues aide.

In the study TNS Cymfony had provided social media comment analysis, I’m assuming from the standard mix of primarily Twitter and Blog data. Compete had analyzed website traffic data. Unilever’s Bob Bowan commented that “engagement” (comments), “solutions” (sites where information was consumed), and “purchase” were occurring in completely separate online locations. The consolidation of which obviously represent a great opportunity for those who can do a better job creating credible and engaging content sites within their category. Unfortunately, as of today I rarely see this happening in practice.

At the GRIT party later that evening my friend Larry Friedman, CRO at TNS, said it well “Most are just focusing on the ‘Media’ component of ‘Social Media’, they are missing the ‘social’”. I do think brands can get there, but it will take some time to change the corporate mindset. Companies must be willing to yield more control to the customer for it to happen.

The second case study was presented by Pattii Wakeling of Unilever and John Burbank, CEO of Nielsen Online. I noticed Facebook was in attendance as well, and it’s nice to see that one social network is interested in at least the advertising related side of the market research industry (Google was also present).

Nielsen, through their relationship with Facebook, has been able to leverage users Facebook cookies allowing for a much broader level of tracking ever previously possible. This is exciting as it allows for research far more representative than traditional panel related methodologies.

By leveraging other options available today I believe it’s possible to get similar insights beyond facebook, but doing it via facebook is obviously an attractive option for Nielsen as the privacy concerns are then in facebook’s court.

Discussing the issue later with Mark Michelson of the newly formed Mobile Marketing Research Association (MMRA), we both agreed that the old research privacy standards that most of us have followed for years are becoming less and less relevant. If consumers know we are tracking them online, then whether or not our clients get user level survey information also becomes less important.

Scope of Social Listening

A lighter presentation I attended was one by Netbase in which they had looked for online comments using search topic criteria of comments containing “I like/need…” in social media, and had then compared men vs. women. In regard to food/snack mentions for instance they had found that the most popular comment by women was “chocolate” while men were most likely to mention “bacon”.

These social listening results were compared to short open end comments from a survey that seemed to find relatively similar answers. Both genders for instance were likely to say “money”, and women were more likely to say “a nice house”. These were extremely similar to data we’ve seen in our own annual research among college students where we conduct an icebreaking exercise to encourage fast top-of-mind unstructured responses.

Audience comments afterwards were rather interesting. One researcher commented “these seem to be such as basic level of needs. Is the discussion really all driven by brands online? There seems to be very little thinking… Did you just look at Twitter or also blogs with deeper thinking?”

I think this is a common issue and reflective of the problem inherent with casting a wide net in social media listening rather than more carefully scoping out a research problem and identifying specific sites for a deeper dive. The latter which I have always found more actionable for clients.

The problem lies in the fact that most social media listening data constitute RSS data from just a few large sources such as Twitter and Wordpress. If a client knows of a specific site of interest where an important customer group is active it usually requires custom scraping and text analysis.

Subsequent discussion on the topic focused on the value of visceral answers in both social media and survey research. I think everything has its place, but in my opinion the main lesson as usual is that the more specific we get in study design, whether survey or social media, the more actionable the insights will be.

@TomHCAnderson
@OdinText

[Post to Twitter] 

Tags: Advertising · Advertising Research Foundation · Anderson Analytics · Conferences · Market Research · Marketing research · Rethink · Text Analytics · arf · blog mining · facebook · innovation · social-media analytics

3 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Jasper Snyder // Mar 28, 2012 at 3:05 pm

    Hi Tom.

    Interesting post. It’s possible to see this all as a function of social media analysis - I’m deliberately using a somewhat amorphous term - being regarded as a silver bullet to hit targets in customer service, sales lead generation, market research, campaign optimization etc..

    As you suggest, with a maturing market we’ll start to see more specificity in terms of study design (and commensurately higher expectations in terms of sophistication of supplier methodology). I posted something this morning which goes into a little detail on that subject, maybe of interest: http://blog.converseon.com/2012/03/28/how-to-use-social-media-for-market-research

    Jasper

  • 2 Cathy Harrison // Mar 30, 2012 at 9:51 am

    Interesting read Tom - thanks! I agree with your comment about the need to dig into specific sites to answer your client’s research questions. Although it’s useful to use social media listening tools to see the range of topics being discussed, for actionable insights, it usually comes down to an in-depth qualitative analysis of conversations on forums.

  • 3 Tom H C Anderson // Mar 31, 2012 at 11:12 am

    Thank Cathy,

    Perhaps. Personally I much prefer in-depth quantitative analysis of that discussion ;)

    Perhaps that’s another reason “Text Analytics” has overtaken “Text Mining” in terms of overall use as the general term to describe using software for analysis of unstructured data. It’s broader than text mining, but I miss text mining and feel it is more accurate about what can really be offered further down the value chain of unstructured data analysis.

Leave a Comment