Tom H. C. Anderson - Next Gen Market Research™Creative Writing Portsmouth University Creative Writing University Queensland Creative Writing Queen University Queen#39s University Belfast Creative Writing Mfa Creative Writing Queens University Charlotte Queen#39s University Mfa Creative Writing Queen#39s University Belfast Ma Creative Writing Creative Writing University Rankings Creative Writing Rice University Creative Writing Reading University Creative Writing Ryerson University Creative Writing Roehampton University Creative Writing Rmit University Creative Writing Rhodes University Creative Writing Universities Scotland Creative Writing University Sydney Creative Writing University South Carolina Creative Writing University San Francisco Creative Writing University Singapore Creative Writing University Syllabus Creative Writing Scottish Universities Creative Writing Syracuse University Creative Writing Stanford University Creative Writing University Toronto Creative Writing University Top Creative Writing University Texas Creative Writing Temple University Creative Writing Track University Of Iowa Creative Writing Trent University Creative Writing Teesside University Creative Writing Towson University Creative Writing The University Of Iowa Creative Writing Universities In The Uk Creative Writing Universities Uk Top Creative Writing Universities Uk Creative Writing University College London Creative Writing University College Dublin Creative Writing University Virginia Creative Writing University Vacancies Creative Writing Victoria University Creative Writing Victoria University Wellington Creative Writing University Of Vermont Ma Creative Writing Victoria University Mfa Creative Writing Vanderbilt University Creative Writing West Virginia University Creative Writing University Wollongong Creative Writing University Warwick Creative Writing Winchester University Creative Writing Washington University Creative Writing Westminster University Creative Writing Windsor University Creative Writing Wolverhampton University Creative Writing Washington University St Louis Creative Writing Wesleyan University Creative Writing Yale University Creative Writing Universities New York Creative Writing New Zealand University Creative Writing Usc Creative Writing Usc Undergrad Creative Writing Usc Major Mfa Creative Writing Usc Creative Writing Minor Usc English Creative Writing Usc Creative Writing Masters Usc Creative Writing Requirements Usc Bachelor Of Creative Writing Usc Creative Writing At Usc Creative Writing Major At Usc Usc Creative Writing Application Usc Creative Writing Ba Usc Columbia Creative Writing Creative Writing Department Usc Creative Writing Degree Usc Usc Creative Writing Faculty Usc Phd Creative Writing Funding Usc Mfa Creative Writing Faculty Usc Creative Writing Graduate Phd In Creative Writing Usc Mfa In Creative Writing Usc Masters In Creative Writing Usc Minor In Creative Writing Usc Usc Creative Writing Literature Phd Creative Writing Mfa Usc Usc Creative Writing Major Requirements Creative Writing For Non-majors Usc Usc Columbia Creative Writing Mfa Usc English Creative Writing Major Usc Creative Writing Phd Acceptance Rates Usc Creative Writing Professors Usc English Creative Writing Requirements Usc Phd Creative Writing Acceptance Rate Usc Creative Writing Staff Usc English Creative Writing Track Creative Writing Ucr Creative Writing Ucr Minor Ucr Creative Writing Masters Creative Writing Ucr Advising Creative Writing At Ucr Creative Writing Advisor Ucr Tom Lutz Chair Of Creative Writing At Ucr Ucr Creative Writing Chair Creative Writing Department Ucr Ucr Creative Writing Dept Ucr Extension Creative Writing Ucr Creative Writing Faculty Ucr Creative Writing Graduate Minor In Creative Writing Ucr Creative Writing Ucr Major Creative Writing Mfa Ucr Ucr Creative Writing Minor Requirements Ucr Mfa Creative Writing Faculty Ucr Creative Writing Professors Ucr Phd Creative Writing Creative Writing Requirements Ucr Creative Writing Minor Requirements Ucr Ucr Creative Writing Degree Requirements Ucr Creative Writing Senior Thesis Creative Writing Uc Riverside Creative Writing Minor Umich Creative Writing Major Umich Rc Creative Writing Umich Creative Writing University Of Michigan Ann Arbor Creative Writing At Umich Creative Writing Concentration Umich Umich English Creative Writing Minor In Creative Writing Umich Creative Writing Mfa Umich Umich Creative Writing Minor Application Umich Creative Writing Sub Concentration Creative Writing At The University Of Michigan Umich Creative Writing Undergrad Creative Writing Vocabulary Creative Writing Vocabulary Terms Creative Writing Vocabulary For Kids Vocabulary And Creative Writing Vocabulary For Creative Writing Vocabulary In Creative Writing Creative Writing Videos For Kids Creative Writing Video Clips Creative Writing Video Game Design Creative Writing For Video Games Creative Writing Video Games Creative Writing In Video Games Videos On Creative Writing Creative Writing Photo Prompts Mfa Creative Writing Vanderbilt Creative Writing At Vanderbilt Vanderbilt Mfa Creative Writing Application Vanderbilt Creative Writing Faculty Vanderbilt Mfa Creative Writing Faculty Vanderbilt University Creative Writing Faculty Vanderbilt Graduate Creative Writing Mfa In Creative Writing Vanderbilt University Creative Writing Mfa Vanderbilt Vanderbilt Phd Creative Writing Vanderbilt Creative Writing Summer Creative Writing Vanderbilt University Vanderbilt U Creative Writing Creative Writing At Virginia Tech Virginia Tech Creative Writing Faculty Intro To Creative Writing Virginia Tech Virginia Tech Mfa In Creative Writing Mfa Creative Writing Virginia Tech Virginia Tech Shooter Creative Writing Virginia Tech University Creative Writing Mfa Virginia Tech University Creative Writing Creative Writing Verbs Creative Writing Action Verbs Creative Writing Using Verbs Creative Writing Active Verbs Creative Verbs For Writing Verbs In Creative Writing Creative Writing Verbs List Creative Writing Verb Phrases Creative Writing Strong Verbs Creative Writing Verb Tense Vivid Verbs Creative Writing Creative Writing With Verbs Creative Writing Vs Literature Creative Writing And Literature Creative Writing And Literature Phd Creative Writing And Literature Majors Creative Writing And English Literature Ma Creative Writing And Literature Mfa Creative Writing Vs. Phd Literature Creative Writing Literary Devices English Literature And . Creative Writing Creative Writing Literature Fellowship Creative Writing Literary Journal Creative Writing And Literary Studies Creative Writing And Literary Theory Creative Writing Finding A Voice Creative Writing Voice Definition Creative Writing Finding Your Voice Creative Writing What Is Voice Creative Writing Passive Voice Teaching Creative Writing Voice Creative Writing With Voice Creative Writing Finding Your Own Voice Creative Writing Minor Tcu Vcu Creative Writing Faculty Creative Writing At Vcu Vcu Creative Writing Department Vcu English Creative Writing Vcu Mfa Creative Writing Application Vcu Mfa Creative Writing Ranking Creative Writing Or Professional Writing Difference Between Creative Writing And Professional Writing Creative And Professional Writing 110 Creative And Professional Writing At Nottingham Creative And Professional Writing Bangor Creative And Professional Writing Degree Creative And Professional Writing Deakin Creative And Professional Writing Griffith Creative And Professional Writing Glamorgan Creative And Professional Writing London Creative And Professional Writing Ma Creative And Professional Writing St Marys Creative And Professional Writing Slu Creative And Professional Writing Uel Creative And Professional Writing Wolverhampton Creative Writing Websites For Kids Creative Writing Websites Uk Creative Writing Websites For Teachers Creative Writing Websites For Adults Websites About Creative Writing Writing Creative Brief Website Best Creative Writing Websites Creative Writing Community Websites Creative Writing Community Sites Cool Creative Writing Websites Creative Writing Websites For Teenagers Creative Writing Websites For Young Adults Creative Writing Websites For College Students Creative Writing Websites For Students Good Creative Writing Websites Creative Writing Interactive Websites Creative Writing Interactive Sites Creative Writing Websites Kids Creative Writing Sites For Kids Creative Writing Websites Like Mibba List Of Creative Writing Websites Creative Writing Sites Like Mibba Websites On Creative Writing Creative Writing Portfolio Website Creative Writing Prompt Website Creative Writing Websites That Pay Creative Writing Posting Sites Creative Writing Sharing Websites Creative Writing Sharing Sites Creative Writing Websites Teenagers Creative Writing Sites That Pay Creative Writing Websites For Teenagers Uk Creative Writing Sites For Teenagers Top Creative Writing Websites The Best Creative Writing Websites Creative Writing Sites Uk Creative Writing Websites Creative Writing Websites For Writers Creative Writing Warm Ups Creative Writing Warm Up Games Daily Writing Warm Ups Creative Teaching Press Creative Writing Warm Up Activity Creative Writing Warm-ups For High School Creative Writing Warm Up Prompts Xavier#39s Institute Of Communication Mumbai Creative Writing Creative Writing Xaviers Creative Writing Xavier#39s Institute Communication Mumbai Xaviers Mumbai Creative Writing St Xavier#39s Creative Writing Xavier University Creative Writing Xic Mumbai Creative Writing Creative Writing Os X Creative Writing Mac Os X Creative Writing Software Mac Os X Creative Writing Software Os X Novel Writing Software Os X Novel Writing Software Mac Os X Novel Writing Software For Mac Os X Best Novel Writing Software Mac Os X Creative Writing Yale Application Mfa Creative Writing Yale English Creative Writing Yale Creative Writing At Yale Creative Writing Mfa At Yale Creative Writing Concentration Yale Yale Creative Writing Camp Yale Creative Writing Department Yale English Creative Writing Application Yale Creative Writing Faculty Yale Creative Writing Fellowship Yale Creative Writing Graduate Creative Writing In Yale Creative Writing Mfa Yale Yale Creative Writing Nursing Yale Creative Writing Online Yale Creative Writing Professors Creative Writing Syllabus Yale Yale Creative Writing Supplement Yale Creative Writing Summer

More Than Market Research - Gain The Information Advantage

Tom H. C. Anderson - Next Gen Market Research™ header image 6

Al Ries talks to Tom H. C. Anderson about Marketing…

January 29th, 2009 · 6 Comments

Today I’m hosting another marketing guru round-table discussion. Al Ries is a real Marketing, Advertising, and PR Guru. Currently he is co-founder and chairman of Ries & Ries with his partner and daughter, Laura Ries who I interviewed last April.

Along with Jack Trout (see March 8th Post), Ries coined the term “positioning“, as related to the field of marketing, and authored Positioning: The Battle For Your Mind, an industry standard on the subject. Al was selected as one of the most influential people in the field of public relations in the 20th century by PR Week magazine and has written a number of books that have made the BusinessWeek best seller list.

 

Tom: It’s always interesting for me to hear where business thought leaders like yourself get your own inspiration. What are your favorite business authors, blogs or publications?

Al: I have several thousand books in my personal library and I suppose I have learned something from each of them.

But you can’t be a good marketing consultant by reading books or blogs. I find that my essential reading includes most of the major business magazines and newspapers: The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, Financial Times, BusinessWeek, Fortune, Forbes and a dozens of other trade and business publications.

A good marketing consultant has to be aware of new trends, ideas and concepts before they get digested and published by others. Innovation is not limited to engineers and scientists. Marketing people can and should be innovative, too.

Furthermore, there is a big difference between common sense and marketing sense. Extensive reading of the business press will help a person develop good marketing sense which may be the exact opposite of common sense.

For example, it’s common sense for a company to “take care of its customers.” That’s why Saturn introduced larger, more expensive vehicles as its customers grew older, had children and became wealthier. But in the process, these moves destroyed the Saturn brand which once was the most successful “entry-level” car. Last year, for example, Saturn with five major product lines sold fewer vehicles than when the company was focused on a single entry-level model.

A good marketing person will follow the Saturn story over the years and ask, Why are Saturn sales falling when the brand itself is expanding?

Tom: Last year I had the pleasure of interviewing your daughter Laura on the blog. You obviously share several perspectives on business and marketing. Which business beliefs/views, if any, are there that you differ on and why?

Al: It astonishes me how much Laura and I see eye-to-eye on when it comes to the principles of marketing. I can’t think of any conceptual idea that we differ on. And if we do, we tend to discuss the issues involved and try to come to a joint conclusion.

Having been a consultant for several decades, I’m convinced that a two-person team is a much better approach than trying to do everything yourself. It’s very helpful to kick ideas back and forth because the originator of an idea tends to lose his or her objectivity in the process. The other half of the team is always there to supply the objectivity.

In developing strategy for a new client, we might shoot ideas back and forth before we arrive at what we believe is the best approach.

Marketing can be divided into two segments: strategy and tactics. While we are in almost total agreement on strategy, we often differ on tactics. Laura has much more experience than I do in the new media, for example, especially the Internet, which is why I generally let her dictate the tactics in this area.

Tom: In your experience, which area of marketing do you feel that marketers have the most trouble with?

Al: Focus. Almost nobody wants to focus; they all want to expand the line, introduce new products, new price segments, new customer segments, etc.

Expansion is the goal of most companies today. That might make sense, but that’s not the way to build a brand.

The way to build a brand is to narrow its focus so it stands for something in the minds of consumers.

Compare an unfocused company like Sony with a focused company like Nintendo. Sony is more than 14 times the size of Nintendo, yet the last time I checked Nintendo was worth more than twice as much as Sony on the stock market. Furthermore, Sony’s net profit margin in the last 10 years is just 1.8 percent.

Nintendo’s new profit margin in the last 10 years is 15.5 percent.

You know Sony is in trouble because it’s now run by an Englishman,Sir Howard Stringer.

Virtually every company that gets in trouble gets in trouble for the same reason. They expanded when they should have contracted.

You can’t stand for something if you put your name on everything.

Tom: What can be done to address this problem more effectively?

Al: I wish I knew. It has to start with the media, though. Until the major business publications devote more space to the “less is more” idea, it will never happen.

So far, however, the major business publications have pretty much ignored the discipline of marketing. BusinessWeek, for example, reviews dozens of management books every year, but I can’t remember the last time the publication reviewed a marketing book.

To celebrate its 75th anniversary Fortune selected the 75 books that will teach you everything you need to know about business. Apparently marketing isn’t one of those things you need to know about business because no marketing book made the list.

 

The way the marketing discipline is treated in the business media, you might think that marketing is nothing but discounts, deals and coupons.

The essence of marketing, in my opinion, is strategy. Everything else is trivial.     

Tom: In a recent study Anderson Analytics conducted marketers seemed to express anxiety with new media stating that they are tired of hearing certain buzz words related to web 2.0 such as social networking, blogging etc. The overall trend among this group of senior executives seems to be to embrace ‘back to marketing basics’ such as customer retention and customer satisfaction. Still several do seem to feel that these new trends are worth keeping an eye on. I think, it seems to signal a certain level of frustration among successful marketers on how to take what they know and apply it in a new environment. What are your thoughts on this? Is web 2.0  and new media over rated or should we be paying even more attention to it?

Al: Marketing is very much like warfare. (As a matter of fact, I wrote a book along with Jack Trout called “Marketing Warfare.)

In marketing, as in warfare, you have strategy and tactics. The strategies never change, but the tactics do. Just like warfare, the tactics of marketing have been evolving.

In World War I, for example, infantry was the key tactical weapon. In World War II, armor was the key tactical weapon.

Today, the key tactical weapon of warfare is air power.

You can’t win a war just by good tactics. You also need a good strategy.In World War II, the German army was probably the world’s best. Yet their strategy was faulty. The day Germany attacked Russia, the war from a strategic point of view was over.

Trying to fight on two fronts is an impossible task. It didn’t work for Napoleon in 1812 and it didn’t work for Adolph Hitler in 1943.

Companies cannot win today just by good tactics. The Internet, blogs, websites, email, etc. are tactical weapons that need to be used to support a good strategic idea. You need both.

Marketing managers should focus their attention on strategy and hire web-savvy individuals to handle the tactical execution of a marketing program.

In my opinion, strategy is 90 percent of a marketing war and tactics are 10 percent. A good strategy and relatively poor tactics will generally be effective, but not the reverse.

Tom: To what degree can/should some of your important branding ideas be applied in this new media environment? Are there any ideas on branding which you have espoused in the past which you now feel have changed?

Al: Years ago, we felt that generic names could make good brand names. Our opinion is now just the reverse. Companies should avoid generic-type names and use strong brand names like Starbucks, Red Bull, iPod, etc.

As far as some of our other branding ideas are concerned, many marketers make a mistake in trying to apply all the ideas rather than be selective. Laura and I wrote a book, The 22 Immutable Laws of Branding, and we received quite a few emails and letters expressing the difficulties that some companies were having in applying these laws.

We later found out that the marketing people were trying to apply all 22 laws to their situations when they should have been applying just one.

The essence of strategic planning is to identify the problem. Not two or three problems. If you try to solve all your problems, you won’t solve any of them. You need to be selective. In other words, focus.

It’s not easy. That’s why we have no hesitation in publishing a book identifying all of our strategic principles. That still leaves a major problem. “Which one of these laws should I apply to my situation?”

 

Tom: What is your overall opinion on market research?

Al: We have two opinions. Research that asks consumers what they did and why is incredibly helpful. Research that asks consumers what they are going to do can often be taken with a grain of salt.

The more revolutionary the idea, for example, the less likely consumers are going to endorse it. Dietrich Mateschitz launched Red Bull in spite of a totally negative research study.

My ex-wife used to be in the marketing research business. One day she came home and said, Don’t buy Xerox stock. And I said why? She said that she had just worked on a research study of the 914 plain-paper copier and found that no companies were going to buy one.

As it happened, the Xerox 914 went on to become one of the most-profitable new products ever introduced.

We are strong believers in market research that doesn’t ask consumers to forecast their future purchases. When I ran an advertising agency in New York, we used market research for virtually every client, especially semantic differential research.

But with a twist. We were just as interested in what consumers thought about competitive products as well as what they thought about our clients’ products. What we were trying to do was to find an attribute where are client’s brand was strong and competitive brands were weak. When you can do that, you can almost always be assured of a successful marketing program.

And, this is the final twist. It didn’t matter whether the prospect thought the attribute was important or not. As long as our client’s brand was strong and the competition was weak, the strategy always worked.

Tom: From my talk with Laura I know that you and Laura “are not big fans of using market research to predict future behavior”. Still that is something we are frequently asked to do, and something I think we are getting better at. With the rise of consumer generated media, and techniques like text mining which allow us to monitor what is being said about brands and product, do you think this will help make marketing research more effective?

Al: There’s no question the web and text mining will help marketing research companies provide more comprehensive research at reasonable prices. And, as mentioned before, we think that research can be extremely helpful as long as it avoids the issue of “future behavior.”

I believe the critical issue in research is “perception.” As long as market research maps the minds of consumers and measures their perceptions of brands, it’s going to be  valuable.

If you can figure out what’s in consumers’ mind, you can usually figure out what they are likely to do more accurately than asking the question directly.

Tom: What do you think we can we do better to serve other parts of marketing and ultimately the customer? Are there any examples/types of market research methodologies that you have been more impressed with?

Al: Your Marketing Trends 2009 report is extremely helpful to us. Any research of this general type is always going to catch our attention.

Management Trends 2009 would also be a good idea, especially since it might illuminate the difference between management’s opinion on a given subject and marketing’s opinion.

I mentioned before our previous use of semantic-differential research. Strangely enough, none of our clients today seem to be using this research technique.

Tom: Thank You so much Al, I very much agree with you about getting into the consumers mind. We’ve been doing this with new projective techniques. The semantic-differential research also sounds very interesting and I’ll definitely be taking a closer look at using it more often.
 

[Post to Twitter] 

Tags: Advertising · Al Ries · Anderson Analytics · Branding · Business Guru · Interview · Jack Trout · Laura Ries · Loyalty Marketing · Market Research · Marketing Guru · Methods · PR · Positioning · Tom H. C. Anderson · web 3.0

6 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Ajay Ohri // Feb 7, 2009 at 11:00 am

    terrific interview !
    al ries still rocks even after all these years. I remember reading him while in business school and even 8 years later he makes perfect common sense.

  • 2 Ken Scott // Feb 17, 2009 at 5:15 am

    Tom, Al — a highly illuminating exchange of ideas and experiences. Thank you.

    Does “semantic-differential research” necessarily mean that a PR or marketing campaign can be safely built on a semantic difference? For example. Take three great brands — BMW, Lexus, Mercedes. Consumer research may show that Lexus e.g. has the best dashboard gadgets and gizmos. But is that belief held deeply enough, passionately enough, to use as the foundation of a campaign?

  • 3 Tom H C Anderson // Feb 17, 2009 at 9:25 am

    I’m sure Lexus would have a few other attributes, probably more important, rise to the top. Even the mini Cooper which has an interesting dash board probably “owns” a few other relatively more important features. Still, assuming it only owned that one feature I think Al means you should run with that one. I don’t think that’s to say you couldn’t strive to add others. With semantic differential research as I understand it you expose respondent to some stimulus, I suppose it could be something as simple as brand name, we have used actual logos as well as other concepts, and provide a bipolar scale. What you find would obviously depend on # attributes tested and number of brands tested. Hopefully you might have some Qualitative up front so you wouldn’t waste space with unnecessary attributes only to reduce with factor analysis later.

  • 4 John A. Fallone // Mar 9, 2009 at 7:14 pm

    Tom…this was truly a revealing interview!

    Interestingly Tom, you asked Al regarding, Laura “Which business beliefs/views, if any, are there that you differ on and why?”

    I always wondered if there were any areas where Al Ries and Jack Trout may have differed (or still differ) relative to marketing principles.

    Clearly, Al Ries &Jack Trout are still on the same page in terms of Positioning, Focus…the importance of Strategy.

    However, when Al said:

    “…there is a big difference between common sense and marketing sense. Extensive reading of the business press will help a person develop good marketing sense which may be the exact opposite of common sense… ”

    …was he in some manner be expressing a subtle difference from Jack who in his most recent book, “In Search of the Obvious: The Antidote to Today’s Marketing Mess” praises the “common sense” expressed in the 1916 book, “Obvious Adams: The Story of a successful Businessman?”

    Thanks, Tom for enabling us to gain an additional glimpse into the mind of one of Marketing’s all-time greats!

    Kind regards,
    John
    ____________________
    John A. Fallone
    President & CEO
    TRAININGURU
    Office: 1-203-274-6098
    Mobile: 1-203-536-1093
    jarfallone@gmail.com
    ___________________________________
    http://www.linkedin.com/in/johnafallone
    https://www.xing.com/profile/John_Fallone2
    http://fallonebizdevguru.businesscard2.com/
    http://john.fallone.name/

  • 5 Rukhsara // Jul 15, 2009 at 1:32 am

    It’s really interesting interview. I’m wondering whether Al Ries got certain research techniques or methodologies that he considers most reliable for getting into consumers’ minds?

    Thanks,

  • 6 Carlos Frano // Mar 13, 2011 at 3:24 pm

    Great interview, Al Ries is so on target all the time… His comments on Focusing while managing brands, avoiding being eveything to everyone, embracing Internet 2.0 but letting specialists deploy tactics are spot on, though they may not be welcomed by senior managers and advisers looking for a quick buzz on the market or a quick profit.

    In Honduras senior folks have a saying that translates as ”common sense: the least common of all senses” I guess it fits perfectly with his common sense vs marketing sense example.

    Coming from an industrial marketing background, and now beeing fully involved in marketing research, I have to agree 110% with Mr. Ries when he states that true marketing is almost pure strategy… deploying tactics is relatively straight-forward and you have advertising agencies, web specialists, PR and spindoctors, brand developers, media centers, etc., who can help get the job done.

    The limiting factor is knowing what tactics to employ, when, where, how, etc. That is where strategic thinking shines and it separates from the rest of marketing disciplines. Therefore the relevance of proper Market Research.

    In this sense, I am a true believer that any good market research consultant must think in terms of not just only providing insight regarding customer’s perceptions, but in providing such insight from an strategic stand-point that will allow client’s to quickly develop strategies and deploy actions that will have long-lasting results. Personally I get more satisfaction from seeing a client improve its positioning, satisfaction levels, market share, sales, profits, etc., than in performing the research project itself. If your work - which you are getting paid for - results in elevating key marketing metrics, then that is a true job well-done.

    Tom, I have a request… an interview with Marty Neumeier,,, I love his simplistic yet effective approach to brand management. If you could ask him about brand integration with todays ever expanding BTLs, especially Social Media, that would be awesome.

    Keep on rockin!!!

Leave a Comment